Reviews

Don't take my word for it. Take theirs.

Real, verifiable reviews from buyers, sellers, and partners across Google, Zillow, and beyond — every one of them five stars.

5.0★
Google · every review
Zillow
5-star reviews
Realtor.com
5-star reviews
Top Agent
Magazine, 2022
Client stories
★★★★★

"I recently moved from California to Prescott Valley. My husband had passed away… leaving me with the responsibility to sell our home. Meeting and hiring Paul Simari to work with me was one of the best decisions I could have made during my transition. He was so understanding and a good listener — I can still hear his voice: 'Carolyn, call me if you need anything'… and he was right there each and every time. He went far above the call of duty. He is honest, reliable, intelligent, tenacious, kind and loving. He's a great real estate agent, and more so, a great human being. He restored my faith in God and in humanity with how he treated me and my family. If you are buying or selling a home in the Tri-Cities area, do yourself a favor and contact Prescott Paul — you won't regret it."

Carolyn Phillips · home buyer, relocated from California (May 2019)
★★★★★

"To me, Paul is more than a realtor. He isn't a shark; he is more like a dolphin — smart, wise, kind, all of those things and more. After two years of searching, entering and exiting escrow twice, I was starting to lose hope. When I met Paul, that's when things started to feel like it was 'meant to be.' Even after his commission was 100% happening, he continued to be there for me — he helped us unload the moving truck, 3.5 hours of hard labor, glad to do it and pleasant the entire time, and really helped us feel like we were HOME. HOME is not a place, it's a feeling… and Paul set us up for perfect conditions in our new home. Paul, you have a family of your own, and you know how much this means to me and my family. From our family to yours — thank you so much!"

Matthew Zimmerman · home buyer (Google, Feb 2022)
In their words
Zillow★★★★★

"Paul was amazing to work with — patient, extremely knowledgeable and hard working. We couldn't be happier with his attention to detail and the long hours he dedicated to our purchase. I highly recommend…"

Robert Valdes · home buyer (Feb 2022)
Google★★★★★

"Paul is caring, knowledgeable and dedicated to his profession. One of the best I've had the pleasure to work with — you will not be disappointed."

Robert Valdes · home buyer (Feb 2022)
Google★★★★★

"Paul is simply amazing — always available, and when an issue came up he put us and getting the property ahead of his own needs. We're continuing to work with him even after our purchase. I would go with Paul over anyone else."

Pratip Nag · home buyer (Google, Apr 2026)
Google★★★★★

"We hired Paul John Simari to sell our home in Prescott Valley. I'd give Prescott Paul and his team my highest review. Paul was everything you would want in a realtor — thanks Paul!!"

Thomas Wiehle · home seller (Nov 2021)
Zillow★★★★★

"Paul was very easy to talk to. He listened to what we wanted and helped us find it. He always replied very quickly to any inquiry we had and made the process very smooth."

Julie Winn · home buyer (Oct 2020)
Google★★★★★

"Paul did an absolutely great job for us. He was on top of things at all times and followed through exactly the way he said he would. We interviewed other realtors first — we're very happy we chose Prescott Paul."

Marlin Martin · home seller (Google, Sep 2025)
Google★★★★★

"Paul helped me market my home in Yavapai Hills. He is a hardworking, and more important, honest realtor."

Gary Cline · home seller (Apr 2021)
Google★★★★★

"We consistently felt a sense of trust and confidence, secure in the knowledge that he always upheld our best interests. Professional, strong, direct and kind."

Benjamin Isenberg · home seller & buyer (Google, 2024)
Google · Partner★★★★★

"A true professional who stays actively engaged with all partners throughout the entire escrow. He's attentive to his clients and makes sure their needs are handled in a timely manner. It is always a pleasure to work with Paul."

Tami Jackson · Stewart Title, escrow partner
Facebook★★★★★

"A truly kind, honest and righteous man. I consider it a privilege to be able to call him my friend!"

Robin G. Couch · (Mar 2019)

More five-star reviews on Google, Zillow, Realtor.com & Facebook — and more being added.

Ready to be the next five-star story?

Buying, selling, or building in the Prescott area — let's talk.

Start a conversation